The New Federal Enforcement Playbook: Gender Identity Policies Under FERPA and the PPRA

The Trump Administration’s position on gender identity and transgender rights has been both explicit and consistent. On his first day in office, President Trump signed Executive Order 14168, which (among other things) defined sex as an immutable binary characteristic determined at conception, repudiated the concept of gender identity, and rolled back protections against discrimination based on gender identity. Sixteen days later, Executive Order 14201 directed the Department of Education to enforce Title IX against schools that permit students to participate in athletic programs consistent with their gender identity.

In addition to advancing the Administration’s priorities through Title IX, the Department has increasingly relied on student privacy statutes — the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) and the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (PPRA) — for its enforcement activities. In doing so, the Department has adopted statutory interpretations that significantly expand schools' obligations, in some instances beyond what the statute’s text appears to support.

For state and local education agencies, these developments create substantial compliance uncertainty. Schools must navigate the Department's current enforcement positions while continuing to satisfy the statutory requirements of FERPA and the PPRA, as well as potentially competing obligations under federal and state law.

The Legal Framework

The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), 20 U.S.C. § 1232g, and its implementing regulations, 34 C.F.R. Part 99, apply to “education records” — records maintained by an educational agency or institution that contain information related directly to a student. FERPA provides certain access and amendment rights regarding those records to parents and eligible students. Under FERPA, parents and eligible students have the right to inspect and review the student’s education records and to request amendment to inaccurate or misleading factual material in those records. Both rights are triggered upon request from the parent or eligible student; there is no provision in FERPA that requires schools to make education records proactively available to parents or eligible students.

The Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (PPRA), 20 U.S.C. § 1232h, and its implementing regulations at 34 C.F.R. Part 98, grant certain notice and consent rights to parents of elementary and secondary students with respect to protected information surveys. The PPRA defines “protected information” as information that concerns a student's or family's political and religious beliefs, mental or psychological problems, sexual behavior or attitudes, certain sensitive personal conduct, close family relationships, legally privileged relationships, and income.

Under the PPRA, parents or qualifying students must provide prior written consent where the student is required to participate in a protected information “survey, analysis, or evaluation” that is administered using Departmental funds. For protected information surveys that are not required, or are administered without the use of Departmental funds, the PPRA requires advance notice and the opportunity to opt out of the survey.

Importantly, both FERPA and the PPRA have relatively low thresholds to initiate agency enforcement. For the Department to initiate FERPA or PPRA enforcement actions, they need only 1) identify a failure to comply with the statute(s) and 2) determine that compliance cannot be secured by voluntary means. This is a particularly low burden for the agency, especially when compared with, for example, the multiple steps the Department must complete before initiating enforcement actions under Title IX.

The Administration’s Current Approach

This Administration has taken a much more aggressive investigatory and enforcement posture under the FERPA and PPRA compared to its predecessors. Not only has there been a dramatic increase in the number of FERPA and PPRA investigations (and a recent taste for press releases detailing unsubstantiated allegations), we’ve also seen a significant rise in coordination between the Department and DOJ on FERPA and the PPRA. On June 15, 2026, the Department announced an interagency agreement (IAA) with DOJ covering the Department’s student privacy functions. Under this IAA, DOJ now reviews complaints, conducts investigations and recommends potential resolutions.

The Department’s Expanded FERPA Interpretation

Since January 2025, the Department's Student Privacy Policy Office (SPPO) has advanced interpretations of FERPA that substantially expand the obligations of state and local educational agencies. In several matters, SPPO has alleged FERPA violations without identifying a specific instance in which a parent was denied access to education records. Instead, SPPO has taken the position — both in administrative investigations and federal litigation — that policies that could hypothetically allow a school to deny access to records violate FERPA even where the policy explicitly requires compliance with the statute.

The Department and DOJ have also advanced the position that FERPA requires schools to proactively inform parents of information related to their children’s gender identity. This interpretation raises significant questions under FERPA, which establishes a right to inspect and review existing education records upon request rather than an affirmative obligation to proactively disclose a student’s information to their parents.

The Department’s Expanded PPRA Interpretation

On August 26, 2026, SPPO issued PPRA Guidance that substantially broadened its interpretation of the PPRA’s parental consent requirements. According to the Guidance, the Department will now consider all surveys, evaluations, and analyses administered by a school official to be “required,” regardless of whether student participation was mandatory or voluntary. The Guidance also announced that the Department now considers all surveys to be administered with Departmental funds if the SEA or LEA accepts Departmental funds in any capacity, regardless of whether those federal funds were used to administer the survey. In other words, the Department’s position is that the PPRA requires prior affirmative parental consent for all protected information surveys.

On October 5, 2026, the Department and DOJ reinforced this position in a letter to State Attorneys General addressing mental health screeners and similar evaluations. The letter also describes a broad range of activities — including filling out any form, screening, survey, or “anything that can be used to evaluate the student’s mental health” — as an “evaluation” requiring prior written parental consent.

It’s important to note that the October letter and August 2026 Guidance are agency interpretations that cannot alter the PPRA’s statutory or regulatory requirements. Additionally, it is difficult to reconcile these interpretations with the PPRA’s statutory text; to date, the Department has not disclosed the legal authorities supporting the interpretations. Nevertheless, these documents provide important insight into the Department's current enforcement priorities and the interpretations schools may encounter during federal investigations.  

It would be difficult to overstate the unprecedented nature of SPPO’s newfound enthusiasm for the PPRA. Before January 20, 2025, there is no publicly available evidence that SPPO had initiated an investigation or enforcement action based on the PPRA. Since January 20, 2025, SPPO has publicly announced at least 17 PPRA investigation and/or enforcement actions identifying the following as required protected information surveys, analyses, or evaluations:

  • A meeting convened at a student or parent’s request;

  • Consideration of a student’s voluntary request for a meeting without their parent present;

  • Conversations between a teacher and a student regarding preferred pronouns;

  • Classroom reflections about how individual characteristics can influence privilege;

  • The presence of vials of testosterone in a Pride Month display;

  • Allegations of the use of “transgender dolls” in a classroom; and

  • Individual student sessions with a school counselor.

Practical Considerations for State and Local Education Agencies

The Department's evolving interpretations of FERPA and the PPRA create significant compliance challenges for state and local education agencies, particularly where federal enforcement positions intersect with existing student privacy policies, civil rights obligations, and state law. Although the legal basis for certain interpretations remains open to challenge, schools should evaluate their practices considering the Department's announced enforcement priorities.

To mitigate potential compliance risks, state and local educational agencies should consider the following steps:

  • Review policies governing parental access to student information. Examine student records, confidentiality, and parental notification policies to ensure they accurately reflect FERPA's access and amendment requirements. Pay particular attention to provisions addressing sensitive student disclosures, gender identity, and communications with parents.

  • Evaluate surveys, screenings, and other student information-gathering activities. Identify activities that may implicate the PPRA under the Department’s operative guidance, including mental health screenings, student questionnaires, and classroom exercises. Review existing consent and notification procedures against both the statutory requirements and the Department's current interpretations.

  • Establish clear protocols for responding to parental requests. Ensure that personnel understand both their obligations under FERPA and the procedures they should follow to ensure those obligations are met.

  • Coordinate across compliance functions. Promote collaboration among FERPA and PPRA administrators, Title IX coordinators, school counselors, and other personnel responsible for student privacy, civil rights, and parental engagement.

  • Train frontline personnel. Provide practical guidance to teachers, counselors, administrators, and other employees who may receive sensitive student disclosures or administer surveys and evaluations.

  • Monitor enforcement developments. Track Department guidance, investigation findings, and litigation involving FERPA and the PPRA, particularly where agency interpretations may exceed or conflict with federal or state statutory requirements.

Schools should carefully assess these issues in the context of their particular policies, programs, and applicable state laws rather than assuming that every position advanced in federal guidance establishes a binding legal obligation.

How Sligo Law Group Can Help

Sligo Law Group assists states, districts and schools with policy and procedure reviews, risk assessment, and developing specialized trainings to help ensure compliance with FERPA, the PPRA, and related agency guidance while navigating related anti-discrimination obligations and state law requirements. We also help our clients prepare for and respond to SPPO investigations and provide representation in any resulting federal litigation.

Next
Next

Last Week in Congress (11/9–11/13/26)